Sunday, October 17, 2021

Indonesians Praise “Unexpected Victory” in Historic Pollution Case | Environmental news

- Advertisement -

Must read

Medan, Indonesia – “I am happy and it was unexpected that we won,” Elisa Sutanudjaja told Al Jazeera, after an Indonesian court ruled against President Joko Widodo and other senior officials for failing to protect Jakarta residents from debilitating air pollution.

Sutanudjaja, one of 32 plaintiffs in a historic “citizens’ lawsuit” that took Widodo, three of his ministers and three provincial governors to court to ensure clean air in the Indonesian capital.

The lawsuit, which was originally filed in July 2019, sought to address Jakarta’s air pollution, which studies have continually found to be one of the worst in the world.

According to a Lowy Institute report published in 2019, more than 7,000 people die annually before their time in Jakarta due to air pollution. The low birth weight of nearly 2,000 newborns was also linked to contamination.

Reading the verdict on Zoom to comply with COVID-19 restrictions, Chief Justice H Saifudin Zuhari awarded the plaintiffs a partial victory on Thursday.

The three-judge panel agreed that the defendants had a responsibility to control Jakarta’s air pollution. He also berated the governors of neighboring West Java and Banten provinces for failing to regulate pollution in their areas, which, in turn, had affected the capital.

The judges granted almost all of the defendants’ requests, stating that the defendants had “committed an unlawful act by neglecting to take measures to control air pollution in Jakarta.”

But it did not agree with the plaintiffs that this constituted a human rights violation.

The judges also singled out the health ministry for “failing to communicate the health risks due to air pollution” when rendering the verdict.

‘One small step’

Several of the plaintiffs told Al Jazeera that they became involved in the case because of their personal experience with the suffocating smog in Jakarta and their concerns about potential health risks to themselves and their families.

Chief Justice H Saifudin Zuhri (center) reads the verdict awarding partial victory to the plaintiffs [Jakarta Clean Air Initiative Coalition via Al Jazeera]

Sutanudjaja said that the first thing that worried her was the effect of the toxic air in the capital when she became pregnant.

On Thursday, she posted a photo of her daughter on social media, calling the verdict “a small effort to ensure that this girl’s future is better.”

“But I am also aware that this is only a small step towards progress on a very long journey,” he told Al Jazeera. “Especially to make sure the court’s orders are carried out and properly implemented.”

The court ordered the defendants to ensure that Jakarta’s air meets applicable ambient air quality standards and to formulate an action plan to control air pollution.

Chief Justice Saifudin also ordered the defendants to implement emissions tests on polluters in Jakarta and install equipment that monitors and collects data on air quality.

The plaintiffs had previously told Al Jazeera that they were particularly disappointed by the progress of the case during the pandemic when public health was already a concern.

“Praise God and a big thumbs up to the legal team that is still young but has amazing knowledge of the law,” Istu Prayogi, another plaintiff, told Al Jazeera. He was diagnosed with spots on his lungs after living in Jakarta in the 1990s.

Jakarta’s pollution is believed to be caused by a variety of factors, including vehicle emissions, construction, the burning of biomass and other fuels, the burning of coal, and secondary aerosols such as ammonium nitrate and ammonium sulfate.

Continuous delays

The landmark sentence, which was originally scheduled to be handed down in May, was postponed eight times due to myriad reasons, including the volume of evidence, as well as multiple members of the court contracting COVID-19.

The delays had sparked some speculation about behind-the-scenes lobbying.

In response to Thursday’s ruling, Jakarta Governor Anies Baswedan posted a photo of the Jakarta skyline and wrote: “Jakarta’s blue skies.”

He said his administration will not appeal the verdict and is “ready to execute the court’s decision to improve air quality in Jakarta.”

Anies had previously told the media in 2019 that: “The people who filed the lawsuit have also contributed to the decline in air quality. [in the capital]. “

The lawsuit, which was originally filed in July 2019, sought to address Jakarta’s air pollution, which studies have continually found to be one of the worst in the world. [File: Bay Ismoyo/AFP]

But it seems that not all of the defendants agree with Anies.

On Thursday night, Sigit Relianto, acting director general of Pollution Control at the Ministry of Environment and Forestry, told the media that there were plans for an appeal.

“We want to appeal. According to the legal procedure, there is still an opportunity to appeal and we are going to use it, ”he said.

Bondan Andriyanu, an energy and climate activist with Greenpeace Indonesia, told Al Jazeera that those involved in the case were shocked by the news.

“Not even 24 hours have passed after the verdict that the citizens of Jakarta had won the case and now we have this sad news that the Ministry of Environment and Forests is going to appeal,” Bondan said. He had been supporting the plaintiffs at trial and accompanying them to court.

Bondan added that it is also feared that the president may appeal since “it is common for the Ministry of Environment and Forests and the president to speak in unison.” The president’s office has yet to issue a statement on the matter.

Faldo Maldini, the Minister’s staff of the Secretary of State, also told the media on Thursday that he was awaiting a review from the Environment Ministry to determine next steps.

Meanwhile, plaintiffs like Sutanudjaja expressed their disappointment on social media.

“What do we have to say about the Jakarta air for the central government to implement the court’s decision?” posted on Friday.

How many children need asthma? How many more must die from the pollution for there to be no appeal? “

The court also ordered the defendants to pay court fees of IDR 4,255,000 (approximately $ 300) as part of the verdict.

Ayu Eza Tiara, legal counsel for the plaintiffs, said her clients and the advocacy team at the Jakarta Clean Air Initiative Coalition view the court’s verdict as a “wise decision.”

“It is clear that the government was negligent in controlling air pollution,” he said.

“We will also work to ensure that the government now meets its obligations.”

Do Not Miss

More articles

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Lessons on the Long Beach Supply Chain

0
I know you are hearing a lot about something called 'supply chains,' "US President Joe Biden said last week. in a speech explaining to...

The observer’s point of view on a united approach of the...

0
Imagine yourself trapped at night in a frozen forest between Poland and Belarus. There is no shelter, no food, no heat. If...

Fantasy Injury Updates: Latest News on Antonio Gibson, Joe Mixon, D’Andre...

0
No, this is not a repeat of last week: Antonio Gibson, Joe Mixon and D'Andre Swift are all "questionable" (and expected to play) heading...

Americans’ heating bills could go up this winter. What that...

0
Steam rises from the cooling towers of the coal-fired power plant at Duke Energy's Crystal River Power Complex in Crystal River, Florida, USA, March...

What protection do parliamentarians have and how could they be more...

0
The murder of David Amess on Friday has heightened concerns about the safety of MPs as they go about their work. Here are...

Austin Riley, the hero of the Braves in Game 1 of...

0
Austin Riley was the hero of the Atlanta Braves in their 3-2 win over the Los Angeles Dodgers in Game 1 of the National...

Gambian Toufah Jallow tells how he survived a rape by the...

0
DAKAR, Senegal (AP) - Toufah Jallow's name resonates deeply in the Gambia as one of the few women who has taken a public stand...

El lado oscuro del bienestar: la superposición entre el pensamiento espiritual...

0
I.Era la tarde del 4 de julio de 2020 y Melissa Rein LivelyEl video estaba a punto de volverse viral. Una ejecutiva de...

Some Accused of Capitol Riots Resign Lawyers

0
Some of the defendants in the assault on the United States Capitol are rejecting defense attorneys and choosing to represent themselves, undeterred by their...

Manipulated Review: Shameless and Dangerous Catnip for Trump’s Base | ...

0
The state of the union is sulfurous. The defeat of Donald Trump did not change that.More than 80% of Trump and Biden voters...

How to get a Venom motorcycle in Free Fire through the...

0
With the start of the Free Fire x Venom: Let There Be Carnage events, new content and cosmetics have been introduced to the game,...

How to get a surfboard and loot box

0
Garena Free Fire offers a wide variety of unique cosmetic items, and to obtain most of them, users need to spend their premium in-game...

China’s energy crisis threatens prolonged disruption to the global supply chain

0
Factory owners in China and their customers around the world have been told to prepare for power outages to become a part of life...

Can virtual urban spaces become social equalizers?

0
We now move into a multidimensional world where the word space has acquired a wider range of meanings. The disciplines of the physical sciences and...

Will new Covid treatments be as elusive for poor countries as...

0
"It is no coincidence that Merck has experience with HIV; internally, with their leadership and culture, they know that if...

Elizabeth Strout: ‘I’ve thought about death every day since I was...

0
Three years ago, Elizabeth Strout was in New York sitting in on rehearsals for the stage version of her novel My Name Is Lucy...

Villar keeps his promise, helps in economic recovery

0
Mark Villar As Secretary of the Department of Public Works and Highways, Mark A. Villar has helped lay a solid foundation that will hopefully allow...

A shooting in Syria could mark a new phase in the...

0
JERUSALEM (AP) - The death of a former Syrian Druze legislator, allegedly from Israeli sniper fire, could mark a new phase in Israel's war...

Lex-in-depth: does Uber deserve its $91bn valuation?

0
Low prices made Uber into a global sensation. Now they threaten its future. Cheap fares kept the ride-hailing app on the road through its...

Aspen Ladd coach Jim West issues first statement after unimpressive performance...

0
Aspen Ladd returned to the Octagon by headlining a UFC Fight Night event in a featherweight showdown against Norma Dumont. In a largely...

Sunday Night Football DraftKings Picks: NFL DFS Lineup Tips for Week...

0
The Steelers host a squad of Seahawks hit in Week 6 Sunday Night Football. Not only will the Seahawks be without quarterback Russell...

Nate Díaz visits Mikey García in the locker room after the...

0
Nate Diaz visited Mikey Garcia in the locker room after his shocking loss to Sandor Martin. Garcia returned to boxing after a two-year...

Best Workflow Management Software: Comindware Tracker

0
Did you hear about him the best workflow management software, Comindware Tracker that is available in the market to manage all business purposes? ...

What channel is NASCAR on today? TV schedule, Texas playoff...

0
For anyone wondering, "What channel is the NASCAR race on today?" The answer is one that viewers will get most of the time...

Fantasy Injury Updates: Latest News on Tyreek Hill, Terry McLaurin, Mike...

0
The consequences are hard to quantify when a star catcher is out, so when guys like Tyreek Hill, Terry McLaurin and Mike Williams are...

Transposit introduces CloudOps workflow authoring functionality

0
If someone selected three terms that represent the IT frontier in 2021, they could choose: automation, automation, automation. Others may select user experience (UX), AI,...

Profit Playbook: A Comprehensive Investor’s Guide to Big Reports Before This...

0
Wall Street favorites Netflix and Tesla are poised to report, as are legacy tech companies Intel and IBM.

France and the UK should be ashamed of their immature disputes

0
The writer is a special advisor to the Institut Montaigne and a visiting research fellow at King's College London. In the Suez Crisis of...

Red Wings ‘Filip Zadina calls Canucks’ Conor Garland an insult after...

0
Following the Red Wings' 3-1 win over the Canucks on Saturday, Filip Zadina spoke to the media. When asked about a hit he...

Chiefs OL Joe Thuney playing with a broken hand

0
The Kansas City Chiefs are trying to reestablish themselves as an AFC powerhouse, and Joe Thuney isn't about to let...

“Give me a suitable captain”

0
Manchester United fans were frustrated by the poor performance of the club's captain, Harry Maguire, in their 4-2 loss to Leicester City in the...

Childproofing Your COVID-Ready Home | Inquirer Business

0
Despite the challenges we faced during quarantine, many of us were finally able to spend some time with our families. We were able...

Directors Expect Their Big Break More Than Men, Report Reveals |...

0
Television documentary teams in Britain today are filled with ambitious and capable women, but most of them have to wait much longer than their...

PSG transfer news summary: Former Blaugrana president claims Barcelona was wrong...

0
PSG didn't count on Lionel Messi for their match against Angers, but the Ligue 1 giants managed to score all three points. The Parisians...

Where is Mikey Garcia going after a surprising loss to Sandor...

0
Mikey Garcia had big plans for his future, with fights against the likes of Devin Haney and Regis Prograis. All he had to...

We put our son in charge for a day, it was...

0
W.We call it your "day in charge." A day in which our nine-year-old daughter Flora is in charge and we are, indeed, hers....

These 5 stocks reporting this week almost always outperform the street...

0
A specialty trader works inside a booth on the floor of the New York Stock Exchange (NYSE) in New York City, on October 6,...

“No one had ever laid their hands on me”: Flight attendants...

0
A.Lexander Clark had just boarded the United airliner bound for Los Angeles when the man sitting behind him became enraged. As Clark says,...

Coalition ‘kills 160’ Yemen rebels as Marib battle escalates | ...

0
The Saudi-led coalition says it has killed dozens of Houthi rebels in airstrikes as warring sides fight near a strategic city.The Saudi-led coalition supporting...

How the Patriots have helped Mac Jones look like the best...

0
Call it "Easy Mac" because the Patriots quarterback has made it look like that this season. The Patriots opened their eyes when they released Cam...

Trevon Diggs interception streak: Cowboys CB nears NFL record amid breakout...

0
NFL quarterbacks challenging Trevon Diggs can find themselves in a hole. The Cowboys defensive back is off to a ridiculous start to 2021, with six...

Syria accuses Israel of murdering official near Golan Heights

0
The Syrian government on Saturday accused Israel of murdering a high-ranking Syrian official who spent 12 years in an Israeli prison on terrorism charges...

Russian film crew returns to Earth after filming the first movie...

0
A Russian actor and a film director have returned to Earth after spending 12 days on the International Space Station filming scenes for the...

jaishankar: Jaishankar lays a wreath at the cemetery for Indian soldiers...

0
JERUSALEM: Foreign Minister S Jaishankar began his five-day visit to Israel laying wreaths of flowers in a cemetery for the Indian soldiers who gave...
- Advertisement -

Don't Miss