Tuesday, October 26, 2021

Human rights commission says the national cabinet should not be covered by secrecy laws | Australia News

- Advertisement -

Must read

The term national cabinet is “misleading” and extending cabinet secrecy to the intergovernmental body would permanently reduce transparency, Australia’s top human rights body warned.

The Australian Human Rights Commission made the comments in a presentation calling for the central part of the government bill to extend secrecy to the national cabinet be rejected.

However, national cabinet leaders are rebuffing attempts to subjugate their deliberations to make them more transparent, releasing a special joint statement on Friday night underscoring the importance of the nation’s leaders in keeping their discussions confidential.

“Disclosure of national cabinet documents or discussions that are not in accordance with the principles agreed by the national cabinet would undermine its effective functioning and seriously damage relations between the Commonwealth and the states and territories,” the joint statement said.

“It would potentially expose negotiations and discussions before their conclusion and impede the open flow of information between members of the national cabinet.

“This would undermine trust between the Commonwealth and the states and territories and prevent full and frank discussions that would achieve the best results for the Australian public.

“In turn, this would lead to worse results and negatively affect the ability of all governments to consider and respond to problems urgently, and undermine the key decisions necessary to generate results in the public interest.”

The Morrison government introduced legislation in early September to mitigate the impact of a recent court decision that would have allowed access to key documents.

In early August, the Administrative Court of Appeals ruled that the national cabinet, made up of the prime minister, prime ministers, and chief ministers, was not, as Scott Morrison regularly maintained, a subcommittee of the federal cabinet.

The bill would change the law so that when Commonwealth legislation establishes provisions to protect the secrecy of federal cabinet deliberations, such as freedom of information laws, those same protections extend to the “cabinet committee known as the national cabinet.” .

The bill has been referred to a Senate investigation after the protest of Senator Rex Patrick, who presented the winning case and accused Morrison of acting as a “sore loser” and seeking to stifle public scrutiny.

In the AHRC presentation, President Rosalind Croucher said that the national cabinet “is not a cabinet body,” arguing that “the use of the term ‘cabinet’ is misleading and confuses the nature of the body.”

“The national cabinet is an intergovernmental forum, composed of representatives of jurisdictions with sovereign powers, and the prime minister is the only member responsible to the federal parliament.”

In addition to exempting it from freedom of information laws, the AHRC noted that the bill would allow ministers to issue certificates that prevent the disclosure of national cabinet material.

Rather, the AHRC noted that the national cabinet’s predecessor, the Council of Australian Governments, was required to publish the results of its meetings, that its materials were accessible through FOI requests, and that Coag members could openly comment on their decisions.

“The [AHRC] it is concerned that placing the national cabinet under the mandate of cabinet secrecy rules will reduce transparency and accountability, and may imply the right to freedom of expression by unnecessarily restricting the open communication of information to and by the public ” , said.

The AHRC noted that Covid-19 had instigated “potentially transformative changes in such operations in Australia.”

“It is important to ensure that the executive branch is not expanded unnecessarily or permanently through related administrative efficiency measures, as this would have negative implications for democratic principles and the rule of law.”

The AHRC recommended that the third program of the bill, related to the secrecy of the national cabinet, “not be enacted.”

In May 2020, Morrison defended cabinet secrecy as it applied to policy discussions between the state and federal governments, telling reporters in Canberra’s national cabinet that it was “not a spectator sport” but rather a “serious political deliberation”.

The Labor Party has been highly critical of the legislation, with shadow attorney general Mark Dreyfus arguing that “at a time when record amounts of taxpayer funds are being spent responding to the pandemic, the Australian people have all the the right to be informed about what is being done in his name and not to be fooled by the secrecy and turn of Mr. Morrison ”.

In their statement, released after the most recent national cabinet meeting where the matter was discussed, federation leaders, which include Labor prime ministers and chief ministers, argued that cabinet confidentiality principles applied to the national cabinet they had not prevented the disclosure of their results.

Do Not Miss

More articles

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Fantasy Waiver Wire Week 8: Deshaun Watson, Allen Lazard Among Top...

0
Deshaun watson he's healthy and has the potential to be one of the top five fantasy football players, but he's been sitting on the...

ASEAN Summit Starts Without Myanmar After High General’s Ban | ...

0
Myanmar not at the ASEAN summit after Ming Aung Hlaing was excluded for his failure to end violence in the country.Southeast Asian leaders began...

J Balvin apologizes for showing black women as dogs on leashes...

0
Colombian superstar J Balvin apologizes for his controversial music video for his song "Perra," which showed him walking two black women on thongs.J Balvin...

What happened to Carl Madsen? Former NFL referee dies after...

0
The NFL world received tragic news today, as Officer Carl Madsen, who worked during the Tennessee Titans' dominant victory over the Kansas City Chiefs...

Life after loneliness: ‘In school, I was incredibly isolated, then I...

0
I. I'm sure I wasn't the only one, when the closure was announced last March, to wonder if I was more...

The Differences Between Online And Physical Casinos

0
Online and physical casinos are understandably quite different entities and offer quite contrasting experiences. There are pros and cons to both choices and deciding...

Complete list of all theft locations in GTA Online

0
GTA Online is about committing crimes in the game to be one of the best criminals in the world. In GTA Online, players...

The US military received a tip about the Iranian-backed attack on...

0
EXCLUSIVE: the United States Military was alerted before Iran-backed drone strike on a base in Syria that houses US forces.About 200 US troops were...

Basics related to working from home

0
If you want run your own business from home, you need to know what the essential parts are. There are many things at...

Your Tuesday Briefing – The New York Times

0
A coup in SudanSudan's top generals seized power yesterday, arrested the prime minister and other civilian leaders, imposed a state of emergency and opened...

Dean du Plessis: blind cricket commentator who now loses his hearing...

0
Harare, Zimbabwe - Dean du Plessis was born blind. Forty-four years later, du Plessis says he is the world's only blind cricket journalist and commentator...

Tony Khan makes a big announcement regarding AEW Dynamite in the...

0
AEW Dynamite will now air live in the United States on Wednesdays onwards.Tony Khan took to social media to make the big announcement about...

The 5 best Pokémon to catch during the Pokémon GO Halloween...

0
There are several spooky Pokémon roaming the wild in Pokémon GO for Halloween, some of which will be great to add to any team.Pokemon...

The royal wedding in Japan begins with little fanfare

0
TOKYO - The last time the sister of a future emperor of Japan was married, thousands of supporters lined the streets as the bride,...

Samsung: Samsung boss Jay Y. Lee convicted and fined for drug...

0
Seoul: A Seoul court fined Samsung Electronics Co Ltd Vice President Jay Y. Lee 70 million won ($ 59,461.62) plus a fee for illegal...

Facebook is acknowledging Haugen’s teen usage issue

0
Mark Zuckerberg, CEO and founder of Facebook Inc., speaks during a House of Representatives Committee on Energy and Commerce hearing in Washington, DC, USA,...

Suspect in custody after Idaho Mall shooting left two dead and...

0
A normal business day at an Idaho mall turned deadly Monday afternoon. According to Boise Police Chief Ryan Lee, a gunman wounded four...

Sadly, the world was not prepared for a pandemic. Let’s...

0
TTwo years ago, three months before the coronavirus outbreak, the Global Readiness Monitoring Board (GPMB) issued a warning to the international community that a...

Australia promises ‘net zero’ emissions by 2050. Its plan makes that...

0
SYDNEY, Australia - After months of debate and delay, the Australian government on Tuesday promised to achieve “net zero” emissions by 2050, unveiling a...

Climate migration expected to increase in India amid extreme weather |...

0
One study says that droughts, floods and heat waves are driving climate migration as the country's poorest are forced from their homes.An increase in...

Covid outbreak hits South Korea’s growth

0
South Korea's economic growth slowed in the third quarter as strong exports were offset by weak domestic consumption due to the country's tough Covid...

Malaysia-based Poladrone Raises $ 4.29 Million Seed Round to Protect Crops

0
Rhinoceros beetles are one of the biggest threats to oil palm crops, attacking plants when they are young and potentially reducing a farm's yield...

Migrants march on Mexican capital demanding ‘dignity’

0
About 1,000 migrants seeking refugee status marched toward the Mexican capital on Monday, as the government faced a call from the United Nations to...

Stock futures flat after Dow and S&P 500 close at records

0
Traders work on the floor of the New York Stock Exchange (NYSE) on September 22, 2021.Brendan McDermid | ReutersUS equity futures were flat...

Zuckerberg says he has redirected Facebook teams to serve young adults...

0
Jacob Kastrenakes / The edge: Zuckerberg says he has redirected Facebook teams to serve young adults over older users, and that...

Scott Morrison Says Australia’s Net Zero Emissions 2050 Plan is Election-Based,...

0
Prime Minister Scott Morrison published the government's plan to achieve net zero emissions by 2050 and updated Australia's projection for 2030 to between 30%...

Tesla’s sales in China have risen to almost half of sales...

0
Tesla's China-made Model 3 vehicles are seen during a delivery event at its factory in Shanghai, China, on January 7, 2020.Aly Song | ...

How Online Slots Technology Has Evolved

0
For many of us, slots are the first thing that comes to mind when thinking of casinos. These games have become incredibly popular and...

James Harden’s quiet start continues as free throw attempts plummet

0
It has been impossible to watch the Brooklyn Nets this season without noticing the drop in production from James Harden. Harden, a three-time scoring...

Biden imposes new vaccine rules for international travel, lifts restrictions

0
WASHINGTON (AP) - U.S. President Joe Biden signed an order Monday imposing new vaccine requirements for most foreign air travelers and lifting severe travel...

Former Victoria Police Officer Brett Guerin Harassed People Online With Racist...

0
The former head of the Victoria Police Ethics Standards Unit used three pseudonyms to post racist, sexist and homophobic comments while trolling people online,...

Tammy Rivera accuses a CVS employee of racial profiling while capturing...

0
Early Monday morning, Tammy Rivera took to social media to call a local CVS employee who she said was racially profiling her. She...

Singapore only has 60 ICU beds left as severe Covid cases...

0
Singapore reported 3,174 new Covid-19 cases on October 26.SINGAPORE: The number of seriously ill Covid-19 patients in Singapore has risen to such an extent...

Marlo Hampton becomes official owner of Peach-Kandi Burruss, Kenya Moore and...

0
While rumors about the cast of "Real Housewives of Atlanta" season 14 have been circulating for months, Bravo just released the official cast list.On...

Top 5 Minecraft Seeds for Double Villages

0
Double villages are structures in Minecraft that occur when two villages spawn close to each other. Double Villages can be a revolutionary discovery...

Beijing unlikely to lift Australia’s coal ban

0
A bucket wheel reclaimer stands next to a coal pile at the Port of Newcastle in Newcastle, New South Wales, Australia, on Monday, October...

Lagarde Prepares to Roll Back Market Bets on Eurozone Rate Hike

0
Christine Lagarde will face an unusual test this week when the president of the European Central Bank is likely to reject the growing belief...

Romo’s comments about Brady’s wife provoke outrage

0
CBS announcer Tony Romo is in trouble with his comments during Sunday's clash between the Tamba Bay Buccaneers and the Chicago Bears.Sunday was a...

Peyton Manning wears brother Eli’s Ole Miss jersey on ‘Monday Night...

0
For the first time this season, Peyton and Eli Manning's soccer rivalry made its way in a big way during the ManningCast of "Monday...

Hong Kong to toughen COVID-19 rules, seeks to open up to...

0
HONG KONG (AP) - Hong Kong will tighten COVID-19 restrictions despite a lack of local outbreaks to better align with China's policies and increase...

Biden fights to save ambitious climate agenda ahead of COP26

0
Kamala Harris, the vice president of the United States, met with a group of top climate activists in Washington on Monday to reassure them...

Astros’ cheating scandal explained: how Houston’s 2017 signal stealing scheme rocked...

0
The Astros are back in the World Series for the third time in five years. Though several years after the cheating scandal that marred its...

Porsha Williams shares the trailer for her upcoming show

0
All eyes have been on Porsha Williams this year. In June, the mother and reality TV star shocked the world by talking about...

How to fish in Elyon

0
Elyon is a massively multiplayer online role-playing game developed by KRAFTON that was released for NA and US players on October 20, 2021.Like many...

Australia presents net zero target for 2050 ahead of Glasgow summit...

0
The climate laggard commits to a goal of net zero carbon emissions by 2050, but will not improve on its 2030 target.Australia will commit...
- Advertisement -

Don't Miss